Lucifer

• Lucifer was at a loss for words after hearing Diavolo’s explanation. Being the Avatar of Pride, he knew treating you like someone else would injure your pride, but he was hurt regardless. 
• He and his brothers treated you like family, watched over you, wished for your happiness and well-being, and this is how you repay them? If you had any issue with anything, why didn’t you just tell him? Why did you pretend and hurt all of them? 
• Your pretense and sudden change of attitude directly wounded his pride. 
• When he heard you returned after all these years, Lucifer frowned and asked Barbatos, “Why inform me? I’m certain they will not want to meet me. Now, excuse me.” 
• You wanted nothing to do with him and his brothers, and he wanted nothing to do with you.
• Lucifer mumbled to himself as he walked away, “You are right; you are not Lilith. She was kind and would never have put on an act of pretense.” 

Mammon

• Mammon shattered when you ignored him. He trusted you and even thought of you as his family, so why did you choose to hurt him?
• Even when he learned the reason, Mammon’s pain didn’t lessen. Was it wrong to compare you to someone they cared deeply about? Didn’t you trust him enough to talk to him about this? He would’ve explained and even would’ve heard your side. He would have done anything to make you happy. All you had to do was tell him. 
• Asmo informed Mammon about your return to Devildom, and the Avatar of Greed couldn’t stop himself from visiting you. He hurried to the castle and threw his arm around you. “You’re back!” 
• When he felt your muscles stiffen, Mammon released you from his embrace and looked into your eyes. “All those times ya smiled at me…was it all pretend? When you said ya like me, was it all a lie? When you said ya cared about me…you were acting?” 
• Tears filled his eyes as he gripped your shoulders. “Why didn’t you tell me the truth? We loved Lilith with all our heart, and we loved ya too. So…why did ya have to hurt us? We trusted you…”
• Diavolo, Barbatos, and Solomon remained silent and watched the two of you. 
• “We knew you weren’t Lilith. We watched her die in front of our eyes…we couldn’t save her…but,” Mammon lowered his head and closed his eyes, “ya meant everything to us. We knew you weren’t Lilith, but having ya around made us feel like Lilith was with us.” 
• Mammon frantically wiped his face with his jacket sleeve and averted his eyes. “You hurt us…you hurt me…and I w-won’t forgive ya for t-that.” 
• He reluctantly walked out of there, holding the urge to turn around and look at you. 

Levi

• Levi felt his heart slowly breaking into pieces. You never liked him? You only pretended to be nice to him? All those things you said, all your words of encouragement were a lie? His chest ached, and he couldn’t breathe properly.
• You were just like everyone else. He should’ve known better.
• He was right to stay shut in his room. People only knew how to hurt him, and you weren’t any different.
• When Levi heard you returned, he slumped back into his gaming chair. He increased the volume of his game to drown out any unwanted thoughts.
• He forced himself to focus on his raid, but his hands wouldn’t stop shaking. Levi was having a hard time breathing and felt lightheaded.
• The Avatar of Envy shook his head and told himself to focus, but tears clouded his vision, making it hard for him to navigate his in-game character.
• Wasn’t hurting him once enough? Why did you have to return and bring all the pain back? He didn’t want anything to do with you, so why didn’t you just leave him alone?

Satan

• Satan was upset when he finally learned the reason for your sudden change of behavior towards them.
• Being a logical demon, he couldn’t fathom why you had to pretend. Why didn’t you just tell them the truth? Was it that difficult to say, “I am not Lilith, so stop thinking of me as her replacement!” Sure, your statement would have pained them, but they would have understood.
• Would it not have been easier to come clear than put up an act? So, why?
• The swirl of emotions building up inside him forced Satan to unleash his wrath. In his blind-rage state, he nearly injured some of his brothers, but Lucifer and Diavolo managed to get him under control before he did something he regretted.
• When Satan heard you returned, he simply replied, “I see.”
• He didn’t want anything to do with you. The last thing Satan wanted was for his wrath to get out of hand again. He didn’t want to hurt any of his brothers, especially not because of you.
• Granted, he never met Lilith, but he knew how much his brothers cared for her. He had heard stories and shared Lucifer’s visions, and Satan knew for sure that you weren’t Lilith, and you would never be like her.

Asmo

• Asmo couldn’t believe his ears and could only stare at Diavolo with wide eyes. It never dawned on him that he and his brothers were treating you as a replacement for Lilith.
• Though your pretense hurt him, he could understand your point of view. If someone treated him as a replacement, he would be upset with them as well.
• When Asmo heard you returned to Devildom, he wasn’t sure how to feel. He wanted to meet you but knew you didn’t want to see him. The Avatar of Lust decided to visit you, considering he wanted to apologize to you.
• Asmo slowly walked up behind you and spoke softly. “Hi, sweetie. I’m glad to see you’re doing well. You may not want to see me, but please listen to what I have to say.”
• He stepped in front of you and took your hands in his. “Sweetie, I am so sorry for hurting your feelings. I don’t blame you for what you did, but dear, why didn’t you tell us? You didn’t have to pretend. If you had spoken up back then, we would have mend our ways. All of us missed our beloved sister, so…”
• Seeing your expressionless face, Asmo changed subjects. “Anyway, I simply wanted to apologize to you. Please take care of yourself, and sweetie, you look beautiful.”
• Asmo forced a smile before releasing your hands and walking away.

Beel

• When Diavolo told everyone what you said to him, Beel broke.
• He knew you weren’t Lilith but having you around lessened his guilt for not being able to save his sister. Learning that you didn’t like being Lilith’s replacement, Beel was in turmoil.
• The demon truly cared about you and thought you cared for him as well. He even shared his food with you, so why did you hate him? Was seeing you as Lilith bad?
• When you returned to Devildom as an adult, Beel got so excited that he forgot what happened in the past and came to meet you. But when he saw your bitter expression, he froze.
• Beel approached you and tugged on your sleeve. “I missed…you. Are you doing okay?”
• You chose to ignore him, but Solomon couldn’t brush aside Beel’s disheartened expression. “Beel, it seems like (Y/N) is still upset. Could you leave them alone?”
• “But…why are you upset? I am sorry if I hurt you.” The Avatar of Gluttony replied.
• “Are you truly sorry? Do you know the reason why you hurt them?” Solomon asked, but Beel shook his head, “I know you miss Lilith, but treating (Y/N) as a replacement was unfair to them.”
• The demon remained silent for a few seconds before mumbling, “Treating her as Lilith?”
• He began to recall everything he and his brother had done. Beel felt guilty; he knew you weren’t Lilith, and now, he realizes treating you as a substitute was wrong.
• “I am s-sorry,” he whispered, lowering his head, “I was happy to see you. I couldn’t save Lilith, so meeting you…it felt like she came back. I am sorry…I promise I won’t bother you again.”
• Beel dropped a bag of your favorite Devildom sweets in your hand. “These are for you.”
• Saying those words, he turned and dragged his feet towards the exit.

Belphie

• Belphie was angry after hearing Diavolo’s words. Every inch of his body, mind, and heart filled with anger. He hated humans but meeting you changed his mind, and this infuriated him. He was right to think that humans are vile beings. He was enraged at himself for allowing you to influence this thought. 
• How did Lilith fall for a human? How did such a caring, loving, and kind angel fall for such a creature? How he wished he had learned of this and stopped Lilith, then none of this would have happened. 
• Belphie’s resentment towards humans returned tenfold. He wished he had never met you. 
• When the Avatar of Sloth heard you had returned, he was ready to manifest in front of you in his demon form and attack you. But Beel stopped him, “Belphie, don’t.” 
• “What do you mean, Beel? (Y/N) hurt all of us. The entire time they were only acting…we were wrong to think of them as our family. We…trusted them.”
• “Belphie, Lilith wouldn’t want you to hurt (Y/N).” 
• Hearing Beel’s words doused Belphie’s wrath. He decided to let you live, solely for Lilith’s sake. For the time being, he was going to take a nap and calm his mind.