Asmo Goes from Least to Most Favorite
Prompt: Can I request headcanons of the Obey Me boys reacting to MC coming from having Asmodeus as their least favorite of everyone to Asmo becoming their favorite? Basically, MC disliked Asmo, but after a series of interactions, he somehow ended up liking him the most.
Gender: gn!Reader
Warning: Mild angst in some of the HCs.
A/N: Luke platonic. Some are platonic, and some hint at the men like the reader.
- Asmo always wondered why you didn’t treat him the way you treated his brothers. Did he do something to upset you? Were you not attracted to his personality and looks? What could he do to get you to like him?
- Then, he found out that he was your least favorite and felt like crying. What did he do to deserve that ranking? He never did anything to hurt you, so why?
- Whenever he saw you in trouble, Asmo would help you out, even if you said you didn’t need his help. One day, he saw you crying alone in the planetarium, and at first, he thought about walking away, but Asmo couldn’t bring himself to leave you in that state.
- He went to his room, got a fluffy blanket, and wrapped it around you before sitting next to you. “Sweetie, I know you don’t like me, but if you need to talk, I’m here for you. I promise to listen and not judge, so please don’t cry by yourself. If you need a hug, I’ll happily give you one. My hugs are really warm and comforting~ you won’t regret hugging me!”
- That’s all Asmo needed to do, and after that evening, your demeanor toward him changed; moreover, Asmo heard the best news from his brothers: he was your favorite in Devildom.
- Tears rolled down his cheek, and a sense of relief filled his heart. You don’t hate him anymore, and Asmo couldn’t ask for anything more.
Lucifer
- Lucifer was surprised to learn that Asmo was your least favorite. His fifth brother was a charmer and attracted people wherever he went, so why was he at the bottom of your list?
- After a few weeks, when you tell him Asmo is your favorite, Luci raises an eyebrow. His brother managed to go from least to most favorite in a few weeks? Impressive, but what exactly did he do to get you like him?
- Well, you proved his thought right – Asmo is a charmer and attracts people whenever he goes.
Levi
- He found it odd that you weren’t drawn to the brother that everyone seemed to like. But that could mean he’s your favorite, right?
- Levi couldn’t stop smiling at the thought that he might be your favorite. The worthless shut-in otaku being at the top of your list, imagine that!
- But a few days later, you ran into his bedroom and said Asmo was your favorite. Levi sunk into his gaming chair and forced a smile. Of course, you would like someone who was princely and handsome. Why would anyone like a shut-in otaku who can’t do anything?
Satan
- Satan wasn’t surprised when he learned that Asmo was at the bottom of your favorite list. Makes sense, not everyone likes everyone. Saying that, Satan still couldn’t understand why Asmo’s charms didn’t work on you.
- Even more than that, he wanted to know the ranking of everyone on your list. He wondered where his name was, but out of respect, Satan didn’t ask. Maybe one day you would tell him.
- When you broke the news to him about Asmo being your favorite, Satan chuckled. Never mind, Asmo’s charm worked on you…meaning his brother can charm anyone.
Mammon
- Mammon smiled when you told him Asmo is your least favorite. That just means Mammon the Great is your favorite, so of course, Asmo doesn’t stand a chance.
- For the next few weeks, Mammon was happy, thinking he was at the very top of your favorites list. Then, out of nowhere, you told him that Asmo was your favorite. How in the devil’s name did his younger brother go from least to most favorite? What did he do?
- Mammon was hurt and couldn’t accept that he was not your favorite, but at the same time, he was happy for Asmo. Guess he should have seen this coming, especially considering that his younger brother knows how to charm people.
Beel
- Beel was surprised to hear about your least favorite being Asmo. Usually, everyone is drawn to his sweet and fun-loving personality; moreover, Asmo doesn’t have any traits that people wouldn’t like.
- Even after a few days passed, Beel couldn’t stop thinking about what you said. He really wanted you to get along with all the brothers and like them, so hearing you say that one of the brothers was your least favorite hurt him.
- The moment you broke the good news to him, Beel was relieved. But he began to wonder if any of the other brothers were on the bottom of your list. Should he ask?
Belphie
- Belphie chuckled and couldn’t get over the fact that someone disliked Asmo. He didn’t think that was possible, but you made the impossible possible.
- When he was not napping, Belphie wondered what Asmo did to make you dislike him. Maybe you didn’t like him getting into your personal space? Did you not like his bubbly personality?
- Belphie was not surprised when you told him Asmo’s new rank on your list. What do you know…Asmo really was a charmer, and no one could resist him, after all. But…what rank was he on your list?
Diavolo
- Diavolo couldn’t understand how you could resist Asmo’s charisma. Even he, the prince of Devildom, was drawn to Asmo’s fun-loving personality.
- While absentmindedly signing papers, he would think about you and Asmo. Could it be that you dislike the way Asmo flirts with everyone? Could it be that you aren’t fond of him being touchy-feely? Maybe his obsession with skincare irritated you?
- His train of thought was interrupted when you knocked on the door and entered. What is this? Asmo was now your favorite? Diavolo laughed – so he was right to think no one could resist his charm. Asmo must have done something to win your heart. Good for him.
- But a new question lingered in the prince’s mind: so if Asmo is now your favorite, who is your least favorite?
Simeon
- Simeon thought it was unusual for someone to dislike Asmo, but there was a first for everything. Could it be that you don’t like his narcissistic side? He can be self-centered at times – could that be it?
- He felt a bit bad for the fifth brother, especially since Asmo was trying hard to win your heart.
- When you told him about the sudden change of heart, the angel wondered what Asmo did to take such a huge leap in your favorites list.
- Simeon hoped he didn’t drop too many ranks on your list…maybe he should try harder to get your attention?
Luke
- You don’t like Asmo? Luke was confused as he thought Asmo was one of the less frightening demons in Devildom.
- But your choice was your choice, so he didn’t want to judge your choice. Maybe Asmo did something to make you dislike him.
- Once Luke learned that Asmo became your favorite, he was initially happy. He knew it -the fifth brother was not scary. Then it dawned upon the young angel: Asmo was your favorite? But Luke thought he was your favorite…
Barbatos
- Barbatos chuckled after you told him about Asmo being your least favorite. He said you shouldn’t fix your view on others as you never know when they will win your heart.
- At first, you didn’t understand what the butler meant, but after the evening with Asmo, Barb’s words made perfect sense.
- Once you told Barbatos this and asked him if he looked into the future, he replied, “I did not. I merely used common sense to deduce the result. Ah, but I must ask, if Asmo is your favorite, who might be your least favorite? I do hope you will not say my name.”
Solomon
- Solomon was taken aback by your statement. You don’t like Asmo? Why? He was rather talented at charming those around him, so how did his charisma fail him?
- Did Asmo attempt to flirt with you and make you uncomfortable? If that was the case, Solomon could understand as Asmo doesn’t know when to stop with flattery; moreover, he enjoys invading personal space.
- The sorcerer had a good laugh when he learned that Asmo was now your favorite. He should have seen this coming. Regardless, two of Solomon’s most favorite beings get along, and he couldn’t ask for anything more.